Known for its casual-chic vibe and eclectic menu, Indigo Café is among the most popular restaurants in Cable Beach. The candlelit dining room is decorated with colorful local artwork, including pieces by well-known painter Brent Malone, whose daughter Marysa owns the café. In the kitchen, chef Jeffrey Pineda prepares inventive sushi rolls, while co-chef Heinz Hille crafts a variety of island-inspired international dishes. Options range from the signature conch chowder, flavored with red curry and coconut milk, to beef tenderloin topped with peppercorn sauce. For dessert, try the traditional guava duff—steamed guava pudding topped with warm brandy butter sauce.