Pi Pizza is a traditional Italian taverna in a nondescript mid-island building. The hospitality of its owners and the Neopolitan pizza makes it a favorite year-round destination. Pi sticks to the classics—lasagna, manicotti, and pizzas cooked in their wood-fired oven. What sets this restaurant apart is how consistently it delivers the best versions of Italian dishes without any fuss (and for a reasonable price). During the summer months, order your pizza for pick-up a few hours in advance. Rather than crowding into their cozy dining room (which is perfect for a winter night), take your pie to the North Shore with some Cisco beers to watch the sunset.