Milk & Cookies Bakery
Evoking the comforting atmosphere of a home kitchen, this West Village bakery contains a fireplace, bright blue tiled tables, and glass jars filled with freshly baked cookies. The menu includes traditional cookie flavors like sugar and chocolate chip (the top seller) as well as more unusual options like the Bacon Smack, which includes maple syrup, candied smoked bacon, dried cranberry, and dark chocolate. The bakery also has a design-your-own-dozen option and a variety of ice cream sandwiches, such as the Sweetheart—strawberry ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies. Treats can be paired with organic milk or specialty coffee drinks.
The ice cream sandwiches have more cookie than ice cream, so if you prefer the opposite, simply order a scoop of ice cream and a single cookie.