Pi Pizza
  1. T+L
  2. Destinations
  3. U.S. + Canada
  4. U.S.
  5. Massachusetts
  6. Nantucket
  7. Pi Pizza

Pi Pizza

11 W. Creek Rd., Nantucket, MA 02554 | (508) 228-1130, United States
Pi Pizza Restaurant in Nantucket
Courtesy of Pi Pizza
Price range
Great value, Local haunt, Casual

Pi Pizza is a traditional Italian taverna in a nondescript mid-island building. The hospitality of its owners and the Neopolitan pizza makes it a favorite year-round destination. Pi sticks to the classics—lasagna, manicotti, and pizzas cooked in their wood-fired oven. What sets this restaurant apart is how consistently it delivers the best versions of Italian dishes without any fuss (and for a reasonable price). During the summer months, order your pizza for pick-up a few hours in advance. Rather than crowding into their cozy dining room (which is perfect for a winter night), take your pie to the North Shore with some Cisco beers to watch the sunset.

Other Nearby Restaurants
Black-Eyed Susan's Restaurant in Nantucket
The wood walls, square tables, and cozy dining ... Read More
The Boarding House Restaurant in Nantucket
For more than 25 years, the Boarding House has ... Read More
Centre Street Bistro Restaurant in Nantucket
This tiny, local bistro, at the end of a narrow... Read More
Cru Restaurant in Nantucket
It's been four years since Cru's opening, and t... Read More
Handlebar Cafe in Nantucket
Every small town needs a good coffee shop, and ... Read More
The Juice Bar Restaurant in Nantucket
In the high season, the smell of waffle cones w... Read More
Nearby Hotels
76 Main Hotel in Nantucket
This 20-room inn maintains the charm of a 19th-... Read More
Cliffside Beach Club Hotel in Nantucket
Visitors who want to be right on the beach—not ... Read More
Cottages at the Boat Basin Hotel in Nantucket
The next best thing to staying aboard your own ... Read More
Greydon House Hotel in Nantucket
Nantucket's newest hotel, the Greydon House, op... Read More
The Nantucket Hotel
In 2012, a top-to-bottom renovation from Mark a... Read More
The Regatta Inn Hotel in Nantucket
Nantucket has always been known for its histori... Read More
Nearby Bars
Bar at Galley Beach in Nantucket
A venerable, family-owned restaurant since 1958... Read More
The Chicken Box Bar in Nantucket
Known simply as "The Box" to islanders, this fa... Read More
Cisco Brewers Bar in Nantucket
This cluster of buildings on the way to Cisco B... Read More
Millie's Bar in Nantucket
Madaket Millie's is always packed in the summer... Read More
Summer House Beachside Bistro Bar in Nantucket
The Summer House is an island establishment wit... Read More
The Nautilus Bar in Nantucket
This newish bar and restaurant is known for its... Read More