Hotel La Catalina

The hotel is set in a Day-Glo–colored tropical garden on a hill overlooking the nearby fishing town of Cabrera. Better suited for peace-seekers than partygoers, most of the 32 quiet suites and condos are equipped with large beds, kitchenettes, and private bougainvillea-fringed balconies (all have ocean views). Swim in one of the two pools on the hotel’s manicured grounds, or head to the beach: some of the island’s best (Caleton, Playa Grande, Orchid Bay, Diamante, La Entrada) are a short drive away.