"At the St. James Club, we took one of the Hobie Cats and cruised around quiet Mamora Bay." 800/858-4618; www.eliteislandresorts.com; doubles from $350.—MANDI BAILEY, GULF BREEZE, FLA.
"We set out from Marsh Harbour on a chartered sailboat and meandered: we sipped rum punch at the Abaco Inn, collected seashells off Tilloo Bank, and built sand castles on stunning Treasure Cay." 888/952-8420; www.moorings.com; five-day cruise from $2,270. —STEPHANIE MCNAMARA, JENKS, OKLA.
"At Meliá Caribe Tropical, we loved the miles of white-sand beaches, the tree-shaded pools, the flamingos and peacocks strutting through the garden—and the total sense of escape." 888/956-3542; www.solmelia.com; doubles from $600, all-inclusive.—SUSIE BOECKMANN, GOLDEN VALLEY, MINN.
"Mornings began at La Petite Colombe, a pâtisserie up the road from our villa in Lorient. Then we'd follow our fancy—like a guided Jet Ski tour from Grand Cul de Sac to explore the harbors and coves." 800/449-1553; www.wimco.com; villas from $2,600 per week. —LIA SILKWORTH, CHICAGO
Turks and Caicos
"The food at Grace Bay's Anacaona restaurant is fantastic—especially the ceviche—and the resort's open-air palapas, flickering candlelight, and lapping waves are divine." 800/946-5757; www.gracebayclub.com; dinner for two $120. —JOY MCPETERS, BALTIMORE